Jan. 05, 2009

Customer Experience in Hospitals: Patient by Name

Shaun_Smith

Customer Experience in Hospitals: Patient by Name

comment count 1 comments | 892 reads
Posted by Shaun Smith on Jan 05, 2009
Over Christmas I managed to rupture my Achilles tendon playing tennis with my wife. As a result I am sitting here in a leg cast having had surgery to repair the tendon. It has been many years since I was last hospitalized and so I was an interesting opportunity for me to apply my customer experience skills to the health sector at first-hand.

As I lay in my bed recovering from the operation, attached to a machine that bleeped regularly as it tracked various functions including my blood pressure, heart rate and so on, it occurred to me that the one thing that was not being tracked was my satisfaction with the experience. So I decided to create my own ECG but in this instance the acronym doesn’t stand for ‘electrocardiogram’ but rather, ‘experiencecareogram’ - in other words, my satisfaction as a patient with the experience.

So what was my experience like? Well, if you look at my ‘ECG’ graph, which is attached as a download, you will see how my satisfaction levels rose and fell as I experienced each of the major touch-points through my journey. You can think of the mid-point of 5.5 as being neutral. Anything above that point is satisfying; anything below that line is stressful.


ECG chart copyright smith+co 2009

My journey as a patient

It began with the initial consultation. I was given an appointment to see a consultant at 09.45 so arrived a few minutes early to find a waiting room full of people. How can this be I thought, the surgery only opened at 09.00? I noticed that patients were being called by number and there was a machine in the entrance offering little numbered tickets. Belatedly I took one only to find out much later that this was for a completely separate process.

Eventually - at 10.30 - I was seen by the consulting doctor. He didn’t introduce himself or explain what he was doing as he examined me. He simply announced that I had a ruptured Achilles tendon and that there were two ways of treating it ‘conservative’ or ‘surgical’ which did I prefer, without explaining the implications (political or otherwise) of either? Having asked and been told that ‘surgical’ was likely to produce a faster recovery I elected for that. I was then told I needed to see “the junior doctor”. I am all for delegation but not when it comes to operating on my leg.

I’ve written a full article that takes this blog post further, analyzing my experience as a patient and applying behavioural/behavioral science to improving it.

The piece looks at how to apply Daniel Kahneman’s Peak-End Rule, and the Five Experience Rules that Chase and Dasu elaborated on and which all organizations, but particularly hospitals in this case, could learn from in improving the customer - in this case the patient - experience. To download the article, click on this link: Patient By Name - An analysis of customer experience in hospital care and insights into how to re-design it

5
Average: 5 (2 votes)
 
Shaun Smith
Shaun Smith, whose acclaimed books include Managing the Customer Experience, has been a catalyst in expanding focus from customer service to customer experience. He speaks and consults to leading brands internationally. Shaun was recently voted one of the UK's top business speakers. For details see smith+co. To contribute to research for Smith's forthcoming book, Bold Business, please visit http://boldbusiness.questionpro.com/.
About Shaun Smith   |   Follow on:
  • RSS
Categories:
Featured: Moment of Truth
1 comments »
andrew_rudin

andrew_rudin

Jan 06, 2009 - 09:20

Health Care Marketing Needs its Own Face Lift

Shaun: Thankfully, marketing professionals typically don't perform surgeries. Health care professionals should exercise similar restraint when it comes to marketing. While it's important for medical practices to pay attention to providing positive customer experiences, things can go badly when they try the wrong way.

My story (which occurred about the same time as your Achilles heel debacle): I visited an oral surgeon for a consultation about a dental implant to replace an extracted molar. Following x-rays and a detailed discussion with the oral surgeon (board certified), I received a letter containing . . . a sales pitch for implants! Quoting from the letter:

"Dental implants offer many benefits, such as" (bullet) "Scientifically proven track record" (no mention of the study, who conducted it, or what exactly the "track record" is.)

and

"Dental implants are a scientific marvel that function much like natural teeth and enable patients to laugh, eat, chew, and smile with great confidence." --maybe true, but as a patient, I'm not swayed by anything sold as a "scientific marvel."

Absent from the letter: any information relavant to my case. No treatment options containing pros and cons. No facts. Just a hard sales pitch for implants when I don't really need to be sold. I'm the one with a missing tooth!

The oral surgeon didn't sign the letter. The individuals who did lacked any medical title. It was just as supercilious as a promotional letter my wife's nail salon might send advertising a year-end special, except that the oral surgeon didn't offer to enter my name for a drawing for a five-day Carnival Cruise if I scheduled my implant before March 30th.

When physicians and hospitals market procedures in such ways, the effort can seriously backfire. It breaks down trust and confidence in the medical practitioner's judgements. Nobody wants services pushed in the form of dumbed-down communications. I believe if the patient experience were considered, as you point out, a more nuanced and intelligent approach would prevail.

There are great opportunities for those in the medical profession who sincerely want to get the customer experience right.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
 
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <br> <img> <em> <i> <b> <u> <hr><strong> <table> <tr> <td> <th><ul> <ol> <li> </li><font><blockquote><sup> <colspan> <rowspan>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.
  • Images can be added to this post.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text, URLs will automatically be converted to links.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
Are you human? (This question helps prevent automated spam submissions.)

  • September 17, 2009
    Voice of Customer: Listen, Act and Improve Customer Engagement
    Listening to the "voice of customers" is at the heart of every customer-centric business. Learn how advanced Enterprise Feedback Management (EFM) systems can help you collect, analyze and report on customer feedback, to help you build a more loyal and engaged customer base.
    Sponsored by: Confirmit, Mindshare, PeopleMetrics
  • October 1, 2009
    Social CRM: Harnessing the Power of Social Media and CRM Systems
    Two-thirds of the world's Internet users visit social media sites. Now enterprises are rapidly adopting social computing, too. See how "Social CRM" solutions harness the collaborative power of social media with CRM processes, to enhance customer experiences and improve operational effectiveness.
    Sponsored by: Helpstream, Lithium, SAP

View all upcoming and archived Showcase webinars »

MarketPlace

Gartner Customer Relationship Management Summit

[Sept. 14-16, Scottsdale, AZ] In 3 days and 50+ sessions you’ll learn how to innovate and improve CRM across the enterprise, do more CRM for less, and create long-term customer value. Our role-based agenda matches conference content to key organizational roles and project-specific needs. Save $200 when you register with priority code CRMCT.

Global Customer Experience Management Certification Program

[Sept. 30-Oct. 1, Paris] Learn cutting-edge CEM methods from a team of international gurus. This 2-day course applies CEM essentials, strategies and methodologies on Marketing, Sales and Services; provides a framework with relevant guiding principles and tools for designing the best experience to your customers.

Business Analytics Summit

[Nov. 12-13, San Jose, CA] The Business Analytics Summit is a must for anyone involved in the Business Analytics space or considering purchasing business analytics software. It’s a great opportunity to get to meet the companies and individuals who have been working in this industry for many years.

Social Media Tools Week

[Nov. 16-21, All Online] A whole week packed with the newest and most compelling Social Media tools from around the world, key note presentations and career development sessions. Probably the most important Social Media Event of the year.

Featured Links

Salesforce CRM

The leader in customer relationship management and cloud computing.

CEM Training and Certification

Patent-pending methodologies combine the art and science of Customer Experience Management.

On-Demand CRM Software

Use RightNow solutions to create the best possible customer experience while reducing costs.

Get your event or resource listed in the MarketPlace, reaching 300,000 business leaders monthly.
For more information, contact CustomerThink advertising sales.